{"slug":"2026-09-04-not-a-permanent-record","title":"A Shopify review is not a permanent record","generated_at":"2026-09-10T09:40:54Z","source":{"environment":"production","note":"The window is 5 July 2026 to extraction. A presence change is a review we had recorded on a listing that a later completed scan did not find, or the reverse; both come from our own change log, and a review can contribute more than one. Two Shopify-side incidents fall inside the window — the removals of 16-18 July and the returns of 3-7 September, each the subject of its own report — and every headline figure is given with and without them, because they are large enough to carry a conclusion on their own. Returns were only written to the change log from 4 August, so return counts before that date are understated and the true churn is higher than what is reported here. The denominator for corpus shares is the reviews our scraper had already recorded before the window opened. Apps are counted only where we hold at least one unarchived review."},"metrics":{"window_days":67,"corpus_at_start":951527,"corpus_live_now":936112,"disappeared":201591,"restored":56965,"disappeared_quiet":44336,"restored_quiet":7079,"touched":204902,"touched_quiet":48346,"touched_share":21.5,"touched_quiet_share":5.1,"quiet_days":60,"quiet_daily_disappeared":739,"quiet_daily_restored":118,"flapped":57673,"flapped_share":28.1,"flapped_thrice":1802,"flapped_four":442,"flap_max":20,"flapper_pct_low":6.75,"once_pct_low":4.36,"flapper_median_len":137,"once_median_len":127,"churn_apps":7696,"apps_with_reviews":12532,"churn_app_share":61.4,"churn_median_share":33.3,"churn_quiet_median_share":0.0,"apps_over_half":2591,"arrivals":139069,"arrivals_aged":54752,"arrivals_aged_share":39.4,"arrivals_median_age":77,"arrivals_oldest_year":2013,"top10_share":12.4,"top100_share":40.1,"concentration_apps":7696},"charts":{"daily":[{"date":"2026-07-05","disappeared":755,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-06","disappeared":767,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-07","disappeared":2058,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-08","disappeared":3675,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-09","disappeared":2823,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-10","disappeared":2960,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-11","disappeared":3617,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-12","disappeared":2243,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-13","disappeared":897,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-14","disappeared":959,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-15","disappeared":2017,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-16","disappeared":24722,"restored":0,"incident":true},{"date":"2026-07-17","disappeared":73602,"restored":0,"incident":true},{"date":"2026-07-18","disappeared":45607,"restored":0,"incident":true},{"date":"2026-07-19","disappeared":368,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-20","disappeared":342,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-21","disappeared":456,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-22","disappeared":501,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-23","disappeared":471,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-24","disappeared":476,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-25","disappeared":508,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-26","disappeared":466,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-27","disappeared":610,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-28","disappeared":636,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-29","disappeared":557,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-30","disappeared":316,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-07-31","disappeared":714,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-01","disappeared":609,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-02","disappeared":491,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-03","disappeared":479,"restored":0,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-04","disappeared":497,"restored":64,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-05","disappeared":333,"restored":269,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-06","disappeared":406,"restored":125,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-07","disappeared":605,"restored":104,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-08","disappeared":487,"restored":125,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-09","disappeared":414,"restored":116,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-10","disappeared":324,"restored":78,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-11","disappeared":300,"restored":140,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-12","disappeared":587,"restored":123,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-13","disappeared":480,"restored":107,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-14","disappeared":418,"restored":92,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-15","disappeared":403,"restored":102,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-16","disappeared":496,"restored":113,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-17","disappeared":312,"restored":109,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-18","disappeared":388,"restored":113,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-19","disappeared":374,"restored":108,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-20","disappeared":523,"restored":114,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-21","disappeared":571,"restored":163,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-22","disappeared":551,"restored":219,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-23","disappeared":637,"restored":171,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-24","disappeared":338,"restored":92,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-25","disappeared":496,"restored":104,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-26","disappeared":464,"restored":199,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-27","disappeared":389,"restored":155,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-28","disappeared":620,"restored":136,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-29","disappeared":493,"restored":152,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-30","disappeared":429,"restored":150,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-08-31","disappeared":290,"restored":1046,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-09-01","disappeared":424,"restored":305,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-09-02","disappeared":887,"restored":1529,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-09-03","disappeared":3842,"restored":34138,"incident":true},{"date":"2026-09-04","disappeared":8586,"restored":14628,"incident":true},{"date":"2026-09-05","disappeared":3184,"restored":558,"incident":true},{"date":"2026-09-06","disappeared":1506,"restored":365,"incident":true},{"date":"2026-09-07","disappeared":1073,"restored":238,"incident":true},{"date":"2026-09-08","disappeared":521,"restored":280,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-09-09","disappeared":503,"restored":266,"incident":false},{"date":"2026-09-10","disappeared":380,"restored":182,"incident":false}],"inventory":[{"change_type":"deleted","label":"left a listing","events":208233,"reviews":201591},{"change_type":"restored","label":"returned to one","events":57078,"reviews":56965},{"change_type":"reply_added","label":"got a developer reply","events":11052,"reviews":10888},{"change_type":"text_edited","label":"had its text edited","events":3161,"reviews":3023},{"change_type":"rating_changed","label":"had its rating changed","events":1339,"reviews":1301},{"change_type":"unarchived","label":"came out of the archive","events":466,"reviews":466},{"change_type":"reply_edited","label":"had its reply edited","events":293,"reviews":268},{"change_type":"reply_removed","label":"lost its reply","events":10,"reviews":10}],"flap":[{"band":"once","ord":1,"reviews":147229},{"band":"twice","ord":2,"reviews":55871},{"band":"three times","ord":3,"reviews":1360},{"band":"four or more","ord":4,"reviews":442}],"flap_profile":[{"group":"moved once","pct_low":4.36,"median_len":127,"n":147229},{"group":"moved twice or more","pct_low":6.75,"median_len":137,"n":57673}],"app_churn":[{"band":"under 5%","ord":1,"apps":65},{"band":"5-15%","ord":2,"apps":901},{"band":"15-30%","ord":3,"apps":2583},{"band":"30-60%","ord":4,"apps":2334},{"band":"over 60%","ord":5,"apps":1813}],"arrivals":[{"band":"within a fortnight","ord":1,"reviews":60206},{"band":"within three months","ord":2,"reviews":12163},{"band":"within a year","ord":3,"reviews":11948},{"band":"one to three years","ord":4,"reviews":32186},{"band":"over three years old","ord":5,"reviews":22566}],"concentration":[{"band":"top 10 apps","ord":1,"share":12.4},{"band":"top 100 apps","ord":2,"share":40.1},{"band":"top 1,000 apps","ord":3,"share":81.7},{"band":"everyone else","ord":4,"share":18.3}]}}